The specific spatial abilities required for the study of basic structural geology were characterized by quantitative and qualitative data analysis. A geologic spatial ability test (GeoSAT) was developed and administered to 115 comprehensive high-school students. Six of these students were interviewed. An analysis of students' incorrect answers revealed two types of answers: (a) nonpenetrative answers, which were based on external exposures of the structure; and (b) penetrative answers, which indicated attempts at representing internal properties of the structure. Students who tended to give penetrative incorrect answers performed significantly higher than students who tended to give nonpenetrative incorrect answers. The reasoning of students for these types of answers, as determined by interviews, supported the initial assumption that these answers were given by students with different levels of ability mentally to penetrate the image of a structure, which was named visual penetration ability (VPA). The interview findings indicated that the VPA is one of two complementary factors needed to solve the problems of GeoSAT; the other factor is the ability to perceive the spatial configuration of the structure. It is concluded that the teaching and learning process should provide students with assistance in both of these areas.
1.What are the typical answers students give in solving such problems? 2. What are students' reasoning behind different types of answers? 1. Cross-section subtest, including four problems which require drawing cross-sections of structures presented as block diagrams (Figure la). 2. Completion subtest, including four problems which require completing block diagrams that reveal only a single face (Figure 1 b).
Construction subtest, including five problems in which two cross-sections and theirlocation on a very simplified geologic map are given. The students are required to draw a third cross-section at a specified location on the map (Figure lc).Each subtest is based on the same geologic structures, which include inclined flat layers, two types of horizontal folds (upright synclinal and anticlinal), and a plunging anticlinal fold (Figure 2).The test includes an instruction sheet, which gives an illustrated explanation of the concept cross-secrion, designed for non-earth sciences students. In addition, the following guidelines are listed:1. The problems might have more than one correct answer. 2. The layers are continuous and have consistent thicknesses. 3. The block diagrams can be regarded as cut out of larger three-dimensional structures.