In this study, we examined the gate leakage characteristics of normally off pGaN/AlGaN/GaN HEMTs through a simulation study. The Fowler Nordheim Tunneling (FNT) mechanism mainly contributes to the gate leakage process as indicated by the TCAD simulation. However, at low bias, the FNT undercalculates the leakage current since the electric field is low in this region. This extra leakage current component at this low bias region can be attributed to the presence of surface traps. Trap-assisted tunneling current along with the FNT current can explain forward leakage characteristics of the pGaN HEMTs. Our TCAD simulations were matched with the experimental data for five devices from four different research groups to support this claim. Using TCAD simulations, we have been able to analyze several device parameters including the various potential drops inside the gate stack structure. We were able to identify some of the trap levels and compare them to the dominant defects expected to be present in the pGaN cap layer. Furthermore, we studied the effects of different device parameters on the gate leakage process in the pGaN HEMT.