“…However, recent discoveries of hitherto unknown CWC reefs that exist today under rather "extreme" conditions [e.g., in terms of temperature or oxygen (Ramos et al, 2017)], force us to shift the upper and lower thresholds of environmental parameters beyond formerly described values. In addition, laboratory experiments conducted on several common CWC species (e.g., Lophelia pertusa, Madrepora oculata, and Dendrophyllia) provided additional information on their ecological requirements (e.g., in terms of temperature, carbonate system, food supply, and oxygen) (e.g., Tsounis et al, 2010;Gori et al, 2014;Movilla et al, 2014;Naumann et al, 2014;Maier et al, 2016;Büscher et al, 2017) and also indicate region-specific adaptations of CWC to particular environmental parameters (Dodds et al, 2007;Lunden et al, 2014). Furthermore, exceeding/undercutting such environmental thresholds ("tipping point") causing a local extinction of CWC so far has never been documented by field observations.…”