Using Design-Based Research in Higher Education Innovation

Abstract

This paper discusses the design-based research approach used by the Center for Innovation in Learning and Student Success (CILSS) at the University of Maryland, University College (UMUC). CILSS is a laboratory for conducting applied research that focuses on continuous improvements to the university's instruction of curriculum, learning models, and student support to identify promising innovations for underserved populations in adult higher education; to drive adoption of next-generation transformational online learning; to develop new educational models based on learning science, cutting edge technology, and improved instructional methods; to help more UMUC adult students succeed by increasing retention and graduating more students in shorter time frames (thus reducing their costs). As such, leveraging technology and pedagogy in innovative ways is key to the Center's work. CILSS serves as the research and development arm for the university, promoting innovative ideas and breakthroughs in learning.In this paper, we detail one interpretation of design-based research (DBR) and how it can be applied by an innovation center working within a university for program evaluation. We also posit that the conceptual framework and assumptions of andragogy (Knowles, 1984) have applicable relevance to the instructional shifts that include adaptive learning in the curriculum. A review of the literature on DBR explores the central features of this approach. A review of andragogy as the conceptual framework for this paper highlights what we believe to be the central features of the evaluation approach of adaptive learning software. We then present the model used by CILSS when designing and testing a pilot project. To illustrate the approach, we provide the example of a recent pilot that uses the adaptive learning software RealizeIt in UMUC's Principles of Accounting I course, a course that traditionally has lower than average success rates.

Using Blended Learning Approach (BLA) in Inclusive Education Course: A Study Investigating Teacher Students’ Perception

“…The use of BLA for students which is one of the learning innovations in higher education provides a new way of learning [47]. Of course, the use of BLA is intended so that the learning process between lecturers and students is expected to be more comfortable, independent and learning is not limited to space and time [48]. This study illustrates, although there are still obstacles that still need to be addressed by the university as learning designers, student opinions are significant to note.…”

Design-Based Research: Definition, Characteristics, Application and Challenges

“…Other definitions have been mentioned in many papers to express this concept, educational research and knowledge research has been used, but today the term design-based research (DBR) has been accepted (Anderson & Shattuck, 2012). Design-based research is often described as interventionist or pragmatic in its literature, and like other scientific research, involves identifying, evaluating, applying change and modifying, or intervening to solve a problem (Ford, McNally, & Ford, 2017).…”

Adapting implementation science for higher education research: the systematic study of implementing evidence-based practices in college classrooms

“…Implementation science builds on effectiveness research in applied settings—an existing evidence base is essential for designing implementation research studies (Lane-Fall et al 2019 ). Implementation science is different from current research approaches in that, rather than trying to determine whether a pedagogical practice improves learning, it focuses directly on variables that lead to broad uptake of effective practices over time, such as fidelity, feasibility, and sustainability (e.g., Ford et al 2017 ).…”