Learning about race and racism in the classroom may be difficult and uncomfortable for many students (Tatum, 1992) as well as faculty (Quaye & Harper, 2007). White students may experience feelings of guilt as they are first exposed to how they have benefited from the system of oppression, while other students might feel helpless and hopeless in the struggle for racial justice. Therefore, teaching about race and racism can be challenging, as faculty have to account for uncomfortable feelings, emotions, and reactions from students, while also being intentional about aligning course content with learning objectives. Faculty members often play the dual roles of counselor and teacher in these situations in order to help students make meaning of their personal experiences while simultaneously teaching them about theory. With skillful guidance and support, students may feel a sense of responsibility to create transformative change within the system of oppression (Kernahan & Davis, 2007).This paper examines the experiences of three faculty of color teaching a course on race and racism in education over a three-year period. It chronicles the challenges that we faced in anticipation of the course, key moments and interactions with students in the classroom, and reflections on these experiences. It also provides a written account of our experiences as raced and gendered bodies, and the ways these complicated and contentious labels and intersections played out in the classroom environment. Through the examination of our experiences, this study will add to the literature on understanding the challenges that faculty of color face in teaching students about racism and oppression. This analysis will use Critical Race Theory (CRT) as a theoretical framework to understand our learning and teaching experiences in teaching a graduate-level CRT course at a prestigious East Coast university. Given that we served as investigators within this study as well as participants, this paper serves as a collaborative autoethnography of our challenges, dilemmas, and reflections of being a multicultural teaching team working with a multicultural graduate student population in a context that is often framed as post-racial (CITATION?). While much of the research regarding CRT and education focuses on the use of CRT as a lens to