A triangular parabolic cross vault, that was designed by Musmeci in the 1950s as a reinforced concrete structure but remained unbuilt, is revisited from the original perspective of its reinvention as a masonry structure. In the framework of static limit analysis under classical Heyman’s assumptions, a generalized thrust network analysis is adopted for a structural safety assessment. The performances of the vault, subject to its self-weight, are investigated through minimum-thrust and minimum-thickness analyses by conforming to the original geometry and assuming the vault thickness as the only design parameter. Further insight is achieved by exploring a more general class of triangular parabolic masonry cross vaults, whose rise-to-span ratio is an additional design parameter. The static efficiency of the smart and unconventional geometry proposed by Musmeci is thus proven, motivating the possibility of bringing it to new life in the form of a masonry structure.