Existing research has failed to develop a satisfactory theoretical explanation for journalists' decisions about which crimes to highlight and which to ignore. We proposed that four forms of deviance (normative deviance, statistical deviance, status deviance, and cultural deviance) account for much of the variation in decisions about crime news. To test deviance-based explanations for crime news, we conducted a comprehensive investigation of Milwaukee, WI, homicides and how two newspapers covered them. We used content analysis and interviews with journalists. The results showed that the newsworthiness of a homicide is enhanced when Whites are suspects or victims, males are suspects, and victims are females, children, or senior citizens. We concluded that status deviance and cultural deviance are important components of newsworthiness and that statistical deviance (unusualness) may be much less important than commonly assumed.
Abstract. This article presents the findings of a panel study
of Canadian journalists, focusing on changes in their views about the
social and political roles of the news media between 1996 and 2003. The
results reveal substantial changes in journalists' views over the
seven-year period. In particular, the analysis documents an erosion of the
importance journalists attach to core roles of Canadian journalism, such
as accurately reporting the views of public figures, providing analyses of
complex problems, and giving ordinary people a chance to express their
views. The change was found almost exclusively among English-language
journalists rather than French-language journalists, suggesting the
possibility of an emerging cultural divide in opinions about such
roles.Résumé. Cet article présente les
résultats de deux enquêtes menées auprès
d'un même groupe de journalistes canadiens, l'une en 1996,
l'autre en 2003, et montre les changements importants intervenus en
quelques années dans les valeurs professionnelles des journalistes.
L'enquête de 2003 fait voir l'érosion de certaines
fonctions centrales du journalisme, comme le reportage fidèle des
propos des personnalités recontrées, l'analyse des
enjeux difficiles, et le souci de donner la parole aux gens ordinaires.
Ces changements se manifestent presque exclusivement chez les journalistes
anglophones, ce qui permet de croire à l'émergence
d'un écart entre journalistes anglophones et francophones dans
la perception de leur rôle.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.