Fe-based catalysts for O 2 reduction have been prepared on four carbon supports ͑Vulcan, Black Pearl, Norit, and a developmental carbon, RC2, from Sid Richardson Carbon Corp.͒. Four preparation procedures have been used with each carbon support and the catalytic activities for the reduction of oxygen in H 2 SO 4 , pH 1, and in polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cell tests are compared for all the catalysts, which are nominally loaded with 0.2 wt % Fe, using iron II acetate as Fe precursor. The catalytic activity of these Fe-based catalysts greatly depends upon the chosen carbon support and also upon the preparation procedure used. The results are rationalized in terms of N content at the surface of the catalysts; the larger the N content, the better the catalytic activity. The best catalysts are obtained after refluxing either RC2 or Norit in HNO 3 before adsorbing iron acetate on the oxidized carbon supports and heat-treating the resulting materials at 900°C in an atmosphere containing NH 3 . The surface nitrogen content of these catalysts, measured by XPS, is 2.5 and 4.1 atom %, respectively. For the Fe-based catalyst prepared on Norit and tested in fuel cell, the mass activity at low current regime, expressed in A/mg Fe, is only slightly lower than the A/mg Pt recorded for a state-ofthe-art, Pt-based membrane electrode assembly.Polymer electrolyte membrane ͑PEM͒ fuel cells are efficient and nonpolluting electrical power generators based on two electrochemical reactions: the oxidation of hydrogen and the reduction of oxygen. 1 As PEM fuel cells operate at low temperature ͑80°C͒, they require catalysts to generate useful currents. However, only Pt and its alloys have been used to date in full-size applications, because non-noble metals corrode in the acidic environment (pH ϳ 1) of the fuel cell membrane. Pt remains, however, an expensive metal of low abundance and its cost is a strong driver toward reducing precious metal loading or even replacing Pt-based catalysts in PEM stack systems with catalysts based on non-noble metals. The latter alternative might be possible at the cathode, using Fe or Co-based catalysts, provided that the non-noble metal-based catalysts display activity and stability approaching that of Pt. To the present date, only N 4 -metal macrocycles have been of interest in this respect.