Pollination and seed predation were studied in Silene vulgaris populations during two seasons, one with much lower pollinator abundance than the other. Among the pollinators, noctuid moths of the genus Hadena also acted as seed predators. Nectar‐foraging female moths oviposited in flowers, and their larvae consumed flowers and seed capsules.
Despite a lower percentage of pollinated flowers in the year of low pollinator abundance, similar numbers of flowers set fruit in both years, because fewer flower buds and flowers were eaten by Hadena larvae during the year of low pollinator visitation. The number of seed capsules preyed upon was also lower in the year with low pollinator abundance, resulting in a higher seed set. The positive correlation between the percentage of pollinated flowers and the percentage of seed capsules destroyed was also observed when comparing flowers opening in different parts of the season.
Early flowering plant individuals had the same pollination success but suffered higher seed predation than late flowering ones. Selection for maximized pollination success through synchronous flowering, is probably the main reason for the compressed flowering period in 5. vulgaris, but the high level of predation early in the season may further increase the reproductive success of synchronous flowering individuals.
According to sex allocation theory, to maintain a mutant male-sterile plant in a population of hermaphrodites such a plant must compensate its loss of fitness caused by inhibition of pollen production with a higher reproductive success through its female function. In the present study of a gynodioecious population of Silene vulgaris (Caryophyllaceae) I show that hermaphrodites not only benefit from outcrossing, in that progeny from outcrossed flowers are more vigorous than those from selfed flowers within an individual plant, but they also suffer heavily from self-pollination between different flowers of the same individuals, which could be demonstrated in experimentally made male-sterile (emasculated) individuals. Seeds from the emasculation period were heavier and germinated better than when the same individual was an intact hermaphrodite. Naturally male-sterile (female) individuals produced more fruits due to flowers staying open longer for pollen to arrive via some vector. However, the higher seed number alone could not provide the fitness advantage needed for females to be maintained in the population, but females also produced heavier seeds as compared to the hermaphrodites. Differences in seed survival and seedling establishment in the field are expected to add the advantages necessary for female plants to be selectively plausible.
A population of the alvar race of the perennial herb, Silene uniflora (Caryophyllaceae), which grows on thin soils in open alvar habitats on the Baltic island of Oland SE Sweden, was found to have an extended and more or less bimodal flowering phenology Large individuals produced flowers during both periods, while small, and presumably young, individuals only produced flowers in either of the two periods, or in part of both In the early flowering period plants were heavily infested by the seed‐predatory larvae of a noctuid moth, Hadena confusa, but in the late flowering period only a small proportion of the fruits was attacked by the seed predators The proportion of flowers developing into fruits was consistently high throughout the season Both the number of seeds per capsule and the mass of seeds decreased over the flowering season However, the germination success of early and late seeds did not differ Thus, although differing in number of seeds, both early and late flowers contributed to individual reproductive success Large individuals started to flower early in the season and despite their high loss of seeds in the early part of the summer they contributed a larger number of seeds to the seed pool than smaller and later‐flowering individuals Although selection was acting to favour later flowering during a year with high early seed predation, consistency of date of flower initiation and of relative predation impact on individuals across years was low suggesting that recurrent selection by seed predators is weak Seed predation, although heavy, is therefore judged to be unlikely to cause a significant evolutionary response on flowering phenology in this plant
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.