Attackers target many different types of computer systems in use today, exploiting software vulnerabilities to take over the device and make it act maliciously. Reports of numerous attacks have been published, against the constrained embedded devices of the Internet of Things, mobile devices like smartphones and tablets, high-performance desktop and server environments, as well as complex industrial control systems. Trusted computing architectures give users and remote parties like software vendors guarantees about the behaviour of the software they run, protecting them against software-level attackers. This paper defines the security properties offered by them, and presents detailed descriptions of twelve hardware-based attestation and isolation architectures from academia and industry. We compare all twelve designs with respect to the security properties and architectural features they offer. The presented architectures have been designed for a wide range of devices, supporting different security properties.

The Sancus security architecture for networked embedded devices was proposed in 2013 at the USENIX Security conference. It supports remote (even third-party) software installation on devices while maintaining strong security guarantees. More specifically, Sancus can remotely attest to a software provider that a specific software module is running uncompromised and can provide a secure communication channel between software modules and software providers. Software modules can securely maintain local state and can securely interact with other software modules that they choose to trust. Over the past three years, significant experience has been gained with applications of Sancus, and several extensions of the architecture have been investigated—both by the original designers as well as by independent researchers. Informed by these additional research results, this journal version of the Sancus paper describes an improved design and implementation, supporting additional security guarantees (such as confidential deployment) and a more efficient cryptographic core. We describe the design of Sancus 2.0 (without relying on any prior knowledge of Sancus) and develop and evaluate a prototype FPGA implementation. The prototype extends an MSP430 processor with hardware support for the memory access control and cryptographic functionality required to run Sancus. We report on our experience using Sancus in a variety of application scenarios and discuss some important avenues of ongoing and future work.

Abstract. Security mechanisms to protect our systems and data from malicious adversaries have become essential. Strong encryption algorithms are an important building block of these solutions. However, each application has its own requirements and it is not always possible to find a cipher that meets them all. This work compares unrolled combinatorial hardware implementations of six lightweight block ciphers, along with an AES implementation as a baseline. Up until now, the majority of such ciphers were designed for area-constrained environments where speed is often not crucial, but recently the need for single-cycle, lowlatency block ciphers with limited area requirements has arisen to build security architectures for embedded systems. Our comparison shows that some designers are already on this track, but a lot of work still remains to be done.