A systematic review of data mining and machine learning for air pollution epidemiology

Abstract

BackgroundData measuring airborne pollutants, public health and environmental factors are increasingly being stored and merged. These big datasets offer great potential, but also challenge traditional epidemiological methods. This has motivated the exploration of alternative methods to make predictions, find patterns and extract information. To this end, data mining and machine learning algorithms are increasingly being applied to air pollution epidemiology.MethodsWe conducted a systematic literature review on the application of data mining and machine learning methods in air pollution epidemiology. We carried out our search process in PubMed, the MEDLINE database and Google Scholar. Research articles applying data mining and machine learning methods to air pollution epidemiology were queried and reviewed.ResultsOur search queries resulted in 400 research articles. Our fine-grained analysis employed our inclusion/exclusion criteria to reduce the results to 47 articles, which we separate into three primary areas of interest: 1) source apportionment; 2) forecasting/prediction of air pollution/quality or exposure; and 3) generating hypotheses. Early applications had a preference for artificial neural networks. In more recent work, decision trees, support vector machines, k-means clustering and the APRIORI algorithm have been widely applied. Our survey shows that the majority of the research has been conducted in Europe, China and the USA, and that data mining is becoming an increasingly common tool in environmental health. For potential new directions, we have identified that deep learning and geo-spacial pattern mining are two burgeoning areas of data mining that have good potential for future applications in air pollution epidemiology.ConclusionsWe carried out a systematic review identifying the current trends, challenges and new directions to explore in the application of data mining methods to air pollution epidemiology. This work shows that data mining is increasingly being applied in air pollution epidemiology.The potential to support air pollution epidemiology continues to grow with advancements in data mining related to temporal and geo-spacial mining, and deep learning. This is further supported by new sensors and storage mediums that enable larger, better quality data. This suggests that many more fruitful applications can be expected in the future.

Approximate and Situated Causality in Deep Learning

“…The new possibilities of finding new causal patterns using bigger sets of data is surely the best advantages of using DL for epidemiological purposes [65]. Besides, such data are the result of integrating multimodal sources, like visual sources combined with classic informational sources [66], but the future, with different modes and more data capture devices could integrate smell, taste, movements of agents, etc. Deep convolutional neural networks can help us, for example, to estimate environmental exposures using images and other complementary data sources such as cell phone mobility and social media information.…”

Two-step approach for assessing the health effects of environmental chemical mixtures: application to simulated datasets and real data from the Navajo Birth Cohort Study

“…We note that tree-based and lasso approaches have been demonstrated to have appealing features that allow handling the analytical challenges of the chemical mixture data as presented in the workshop, and these methods are also increasingly employed in the field of high dimensional data analysis [20][21][22][23][24][25]. Motivated by a recent report which used combined CART and variable selection methods to analyze multiple pollutants and their interactions [3], we propose to use an improved two-step procedure of combining the random forest (RF) [25,26] with adaptive lasso [27] approaches.…”

Machine learning algorithms for predicting air pollutants

“…[2] conducted a systemic review of applying data mining and machine learning techniques in an air pollution epidemiology. According to [2], all 400 reviewed articles are separated into 3 main research areas which include a source apportionment, a prediction of air pollution or quality or exposure, and a hypothesis generation. Our work closely aligns with the second category.…”