Economic Choice of the Amount of Experimentation

Abstract

WHEN a new process is suggested for use in agriculture or technology it is usually necessary to carry out experiments to estimate the increase in output that would result if the new process replaced that in current use. If the cost of experimentation and the scale of potential application of the new process are known, one method of arriving at an optimum amount of experimentation is to minimize the total risk given by the sum of the cost of the experiment plus the expected loss due to wrong decisions. The main difficulty is that the last quantity depends on the true increase in output due to introducing the new treatment, which can only be estimated from the results of the experiments. The paper discusses the case where an initial experiment is carried out, and it is required to decide whether to accept or reject the new treatment at once or else to carry out further experimentation. In the latter case the optimum amount of further experimentation has also to be decided. A solution is provided by minimizing the risk' after eliminating the unknown parameter by averaging over its fiducial distribution based on the evidence from the initial experiment. Means for applying the resulting decision rule in practice are provided, and its performance under various circumstances is discussed.

Sample Size Determination for Cost-Effectiveness Trials

“…Most authors have proposed using a Bayesian decision theoretic approach, introduced by Grundy et al [63] and developed by Raiffa and Schlaifer. [64] In particular, many authors [46][47][48][49][50][51][52][53][54][55][56][57][58][59][60][61][62] have proposed methods based on decision theory and the expected value of information.…”

A Model for Selecting One of Two Medical Treatments

“…Maurice [7] has applied the minimax method to (4). The difficulty, as she notes, is that expected loss cannot be minimized for the most unfavorable value of 0 since the loss is infinite when 0 is infinite.…”

Value of information methods for planning and analyzing clinical studies optimize decision making and research planning

“…The use of VOI methods, which are grounded in decision theory [18,19], has been proposed by many authors. In particular, Willan and Pinto [4] use VOI methods to determine the sample size that maximizes the difference between the expected value and the expected cost of a new RCT.…”