Older adults with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) have higher risks for early manifestations of age-related disabilities. The objective of this study was to compare HIV-positive and HIV-negative adults aged ≥50 years in relation to sociodemographic, behavioral, and geriatric characteristics. A case-control study was conducted with a >90% estimated statistical power. A total of 52 individuals living with HIV were matched by age, sex, and neighborhood of residence with 104 community controls. Age-related disabilities were assessed throughout a comprehensive geriatric assessment. Review of medical records and interviews were used to obtain behavioral and clinical covariates. No statistical differences on clinically significant age-related disabilities were found. However, multivariate regression analyses, controlling for education and income, revealed that behavioral (use of condom [odds ratio {OR}: 7.03; 95% confidence intervals {CI}: 2.80-7.65] and number of medical visits [OR: 1.25; 95%CI: 1.09-1.43]), along with faster gait speed (OR: 17.68; 95%CI: 2.55-122.85) and lower body and muscle mass indexes were independently associated with HIV (OR: .88; 95%CI: .79-.98 and OR: .72; 95%CI: .54-.97, respectively). In summary, results on age-related disabilities between groups could mean that public policies on HIV might be contributing to patients' positive outcomes regardless of the effects of aging, albeit gait speed, body and muscle mass indexes were independently associated with HIV. Screenings for age-related disabilities in specialized HIV services are recommended.Abbreviations: ADL = Barthel Index for Activities of Daily Living, ART = antiretroviral treatment, BMI = body mass index, CGA = comprehensive geriatric assessment, CNID = chronic non-infectious diseases, GS = geriatric syndromes, HIV = human immunodeficiency virus, IADL = Lawton Scale for Instrumental Activities of Daily Living, MNA = Mini Nutritional Assessment, PLWHIV = people living with HIV, PNLWHIV = people not living with HIV, TCC = testing and counseling center.