“…In addition to the full silicon approaches, huge efforts have also been witnessed in developing silicon hybrid photonic devices, which target high modulation speed as well as compact device footprint, low insertion loss and as-low-as-possible driving voltage [91,92]. These devices are demonstrated through different platforms, including hybrid organic-silicon modulators [93], hybrid graphene-silicon modulators [94], hybrid BTO silicon modulators [95], hybrid III-V silicon modulators [96], and hybrid LiNbO 3 silicon modulators [97] etc. Among these demonstrations, hybrid III-V/silicon or hybrid LiNbO 3 /silicon modulators present outstanding performance, however, only modulators using bulk III-V and LiNbO 3 materials have been successfully used in commercial products since hybrid integration will introduce new instabilities which additionally raising the cost.…”