Legitimizing the Leader: Endorsement by Male Versus Female Authority Figures

Abstract

Subjects viewed a videotaped group discussion by a leader and four other group members and evaluated each of them for leadership competence. The leader, either a man or a woman, was either personally endorsed (“legitimized”) or unendorsed by either a male or a female authority figure. Legitimation raised both leaders' performance evaluations. Legitimation by the female authority affected the leaders' evaluations, overall, as much as legitimation by a male authority. For the male leader, legitimation by the male and female authority figures produced equal impact. However, legitimation by the female authority figure produced significantly greater impact on evaluations of the female leader's performance than the same legitimation by a male authority figure. The data suggest that female authority figures can be effective legitimizers of both sexes, but male authority's endorsements of a female subordinate may be viewed as suspect.

‘Doing femininity’ at work: More than just relational practice1

“…It is possible that Clara and Jill, as senior women who refuse to conform to the conventionally masculine norms associated with leadership (Ely 1988; Hearn and Parkin 1988; Geis, Brown and Wolfe 1990; Maher 1997; Sinclair 1998), are effectively contesting the related widespread expectation that workplaces (and especially those concerned with technology and IT) should be regarded as uncompromisingly masculine domains (cf. Tannen 1994b; Trauth 2002; Kendall 2003), where male patterns of interaction serve as the unmarked model.…”

Women's Leadership: Young Men's Expectations of Female Leaders

“…Another sub-culture for future study is male-dominated professions and work environments. Scott and Brown (2006) and Geis et al (1990) show that in these environments, men succumb to anti-female perceptions. Would the egalitarian views of millennial men change in such environments?…”

Parole Officer–parolee Relationships and HIV Risk Behaviors during Community Supervision

“…Relationships with authority figures can strongly influence successful advancement [57], and in criminal justice settings, the transition back into the community. Anecdotal evidence suggests that drug-involved women leaving prison often rate the relationship with their PO higher in importance than their relationship with their treatment counselor.…”