Patients and agents – or why we need a different narrative: a philosophical analysis

Abstract

BackgroundThe success of medicine in the treatment of patients brings with it new challenges. More people live on to suffer from functional, chronic or multifactorial diseases, and this has led to calls for more complex analyses of the causal determinants of health and illness.MethodsPhilosophical analysis of background assumptions of the current paradigmatic model.ResultsWhile these factors do not require a radical paradigm shift, they do give us cause to develop a new narrative, to add to existing narratives that frame our thinking about medical care. In this paper we argue that the increased focus on lifestyle and shared decision making requires a new narrative of agency, to supplement the narrative of “the patient”. This narrative is conceptually linked to the developing philosophy of person-centred care.ConclusionsIf patients are seen also as “agents” this will result in a substantial shift in practical decisions: The development and adoption of this narrative will help practitioners work with patients to their mutual benefit, harnessing the patients’ motivation, shifting the focus from treatment to prevention and preventing unnecessary and harmful treatments that can come out of our preoccupation with the patient narrative. It will also help to shift research efforts, conceptual and empirical, from “treating” and “battling” diseases and their purported “mechanisms” to understanding complex contributing factors and their interplay.

The Limits of Empowerment: How to Reframe the Role of mHealth Tools in the Healthcare Ecosystem

“…All studies found that the answers to these questions are variable and contextually dependent, with multiple factors such as trust in clinician, newness or severity of symptoms, or confidence, all affecting the preferences in real time. This shows that the relationship between social factors, rationality and individual's desire to be involved in making choices is complex (Walach and Loughlin 2018). Thus, there is never going to be a one-sizefits all model for the relationship between autonomy and paternalism (Carrard et al 2016).…”

Tying care and respect into a single bioethical principle: On Dall'Agnol's respectful care theory

“…So, we argue that the language‐game of rights is at the core of the domain of the attitudes and practices of respect . So, the new principle of respectful care can be employed by practitioners as a new imperative moral language‐game, a moral know‐how that should govern the health care practices in this new era of taking care of people not merely as patients , but as agents (that is, persons ) …”

“…So, the new principle of respectful care can be employed by practitioners as a new imperative moral language-game, a moral know-how that should govern the health care practices in this new era of taking care of people not merely as patients, but as agents (that is, persons). [16][17][18]…”

Interactions between persons—Knowledge, decision making, and the co‐production of practice

“…[1][2][3][4][5][6][7] Rather, their incorporation into our thinking and planning of health and social care is essential if we are to respond adequately to the problems that confront us: they need to be seen not as "ethical add-ons" but core components of any genuinely integrated, realistic, and conceptually sound account of health care practice. [8][9][10][11][12][13] As reported in the most recent philosophy thematic edition of this journal, 14 researchers are rising to this challenge, to develop accounts of these key ideas with substantive import and application. To do so effectively requires not only extensive empirical work to understand and adequately characterize perspectives previously ignored or marginalized [15][16][17][18][19][20][21][22][23] but also a fundamental conceptual shift in our understanding of the nature of and relationships between knowledge, evidence, value, patient experience, and the social context of care, as well as the social context of research and all forms of knowledge production.…”