Rhetorical Tactics to Influence Responsibility Judgments: Account Giving in Banks Presidents’ Letters During the Financial Market Crisis

Abstract

This content analysis investigates bank presidents' letters in the aftermath of the financial market crisis (2007/2008). We posit that managers use accounts as a rhetorical device in order to influence responsibility judgments of stakeholders. Therefore, we draw on attribution theory, self-presentational theories and research on account giving to develop our hypotheses. From our model of responsibility judgment, we infer how banks will react to their financial performance after the financial market crisis (2007/2008). We test this with a sample built from 91 U.S. and European banks, which were all severely hit by this crisis. Our results indicate that bank managers use accounts as linguistic devices to influence the responsibility judgments of stakeholders: Refusals and to relativize are used to influence their situational perception, concessions and excuses target on locus and controllability perceptions, and initiatives and outlooks affect stability perceptions.

CEO letters: Hospitality corporate narratives during the COVID-19 pandemic

“…The results of the study presented salient appeal types and their unique associations with specific impression management tactics. Thus, hospitality companies can gain some ideas in designing their approaches to the crisis strategically by considering appeal types and impression management tactics that fit their intended purposes to deliver through corporate narratives ( Brühl and Kury, 2019 ). Specifically, hospitality companies will be able to obtain engagement and support from employees, customers, and government more effectively through supplication tactics.…”

Extending Discourse of Renewal to Preparedness: Construct and Scale Development of Readiness for Renewal

“…Crisis communication is a critical competency for organizational leaders (Ulmer et al, 2019). Prior business and managerial communication research has examined message strategies (Bamber & Parry, 2016; Brühl & Kury, 2016; Johansson & Nord, 2018), and contingencies influencing a crisis response such as stakeholders (Mazzei & Ravazzani, 2015), multicultural environments (Fatima Oliveira, 2013), and leadership characteristics (Jamal & Abu Bakar, 2015). Although crisis management is an ongoing process (Coombs, 2014), most communication research focuses on response or postcrisis recovery compared to preparation (Coombs, 2010).…”

Analyst Following, Country’s Financial Development, and the Selective Use of Graphical Information in Corporate Annual Reports

“…This study contributes to the literatures on impression management (e.g., Merkl-Davies & Brennan, 2007Penrose, 2008) and the natural language in corporate communication (e.g., Beelitz & Merkl-Davies, 2012;Brühl & Kury, 2016;Crowther et al, 2006;Dunn, 2009;Sandell & Svensson, 2016). Prior literature has documented that impression management encompasses both the textual and visual aspects of annual reports (e.g., Beattie, 2014;.…”