T cell differentiation is a progressive process characterized by phenotypic and functional changes. By transferring tumor-specific CD8 + T cells into tumor-bearing mice at various stages of differentiation, we evaluated their efficacy for adoptive immunotherapy. We found that administration of naive and early effector T cells, in combination with active immunization and IL-2, resulted in the eradication of large, established tumors. Despite enhanced in vitro antitumor properties, more-differentiated effector T cells were less effective for in vivo tumor treatment. Several events may underlie this paradoxical phenomenon: (a) downregulation of lymphoid-homing and costimulatory molecules; (b) inability to produce IL-2 and access homeostatic cytokines; and (c) entry into a proapoptotic and replicative senescent state. While the progressive acquisition of terminal effector properties is characterized by pronounced in vitro tumor killing, in vivo T cell activation, proliferation, and survival are progressively impaired. These findings suggest that the current methodology for selecting T cells for transfer is inadequate and provide new criteria for the generation and the screening of optimal lymphocyte populations for adoptive immunotherapy.
IntroductionAdoptive cell transfer therapy (ACT), the administration of ex vivoactivated and -expanded autologous tumor-reactive T cells, is currently one of the few immunotherapies that can induce objective clinical responses in significant numbers of patients with metastatic solid tumors (1-3). In a previous study, ACT after lymphodepleting conditioning caused objective responses in 46% of patients with metastatic melanoma refractory to other therapeutic modalities (4). We have now tripled the size of the original study (4), and the objective response rate exceeds 50%, and 11% of all patients treated are complete responders (5).There are several theoretical advantages to the use of ACT in treatment of cancer. Tumor-specific T cells can be activated and expanded to large numbers ex vivo, independently of the immunogenic properties of the tumor. Perhaps most important, the functional and phenotypic qualities of T cells can be selected prior to their adoptive transfer.Much progress has been made in the understanding of the properties of T cell subpopulations associated with states of T cell differentiation in mice and humans, especially those states that are related to the generation of memory T cells capable of protecting against viral challenge (6-9). However, little progress has been made in identifying the characteristics of cell states that are associated with the successful treatment of large, established tumors in mice or in humans.