The Three Generations of Cultural Capital Research: A Narrative Review

Abstract

This article examines evolving uses of Bourdieu's signature concept of Cultural Capital in American educational research. Bourdieu originally developed the concept in the 1960s and 1970s by mixing French intellectual traditions with ideas from American social science. American researchers have adopted the term over three generations. The first generation understood the concept during the 1970s and early 1980s within broader traditions of mobility research, educational stratification, and conflict theory. Between the late 1980s and early 2000s, a second generation produced three variants of the concept. Over the past decade, a third generation has elaborated those variants into three distinct streams. A first stream, the "DiMaggio tradition," uses survey methods to conceive cultural capital as resources that shape student outcomes. A second stream, the "Lareau tradition," uses qualitative observations to interpret cultural capital as family strategies that align with schools' institutional rewards. A third stream, the "Collins tradition," offers the most micro-oriented conception of cultural capital, seen as stocks of meanings that facilitate ritual interactions. We end by assessing this evolution and offering possibilities for a next generation of research.

Literacy, social justice and inclusion: a large‐scale design experiment to narrow the attainment gap linked to poverty

“…The rise in overall attainment was prompted by a fall in the percentage of scores in the 'Low' and 'Below average' stanines, and an increased percentage of 'Average' (for students in poverty) and 'Above average' scores (for both groups, © 2020 NASEN although the larger increase was for non-poverty students). This shortened 'tail' of achievement is an important success story; literacy is a gatekeeper for other curricular areas and whether rich or poor, students who struggle to read are disempowered (Heath, 1983(Heath, , 2008Davies and Rizk, 2017;Goudeau and Croizet, 2017).…”

Managing School Climate Issues at the School District Level: A Comprehensive Review of the Literature

“…This study was conducted through a comprehensive review of the literature using the following procedure: search strategy; definition of inclusion/exclusion criteria; and data extraction process (Bjorklund Jr., 2018;Davies & Rizk, 2017;Siddaway, 2014).…”

¿Segregación Escolar por Nivel Socioeconómico o por Nivel de Estudios de los Padres?

“…La opción de usar el nivel de estudio de los progenitores como variable criterio para la consideración de segregación escolar está más que justificada. El nivel de estudios del padre y de la madre forma parte de lo que Bourdieu (1973) denominó "capital cultural" con una clara incidencia en la reproducción social (Davies y Rizk, 2018). Así, está largamente demostrada su fuerte incidencia en el rendimiento académico de los estudiantes (p.…”