The multiple Birkhoff recurrence theorem states that for any d ∈ N, every system (X, T ) has a multiply recurrent point x, i.e. (x, x, . . . , x) is recurrent under τ d =: T × T 2 × . . . × T d . It is natural to ask if there always is a multiply minimal point, i.e. a point x such that (x, x, . . . , x) is τ d -minimal. A negative answer is presented in this paper via studying the horocycle flows.However, it is shown that for any minimal system (X, T ) and any non-empty open set U, there is x ∈ U such that {n ∈ Z : T n x ∈ U, . . . , T dn x ∈ U} is piecewise syndetic; and that for a PI minimal system, any M-subsystem of (X d , τ d ) is minimal. CONTENTS 1 The upper density of A is defined by d(A) = lim sup N→∞