Vocal Symptoms and Associated Risk Factors between Male and Female University Teachers

Abstract

Introduction Many recent studies on teachers warn of the adverse effects that voice problems have on work performance. However, only a few of these studies included university teachers. Objective To compare the vocal symptoms and risk factors between male and female university teachers in a private institution within the city of São Paulo. Methods In a cross-sectional survey, a voice self-evaluation form prepared by the Ministry of Labor in Brazil was administered to 846 university teachers at a private institution in the city of São Paulo. Results The percentage of hoarseness, vocal tract discomfort, neck pain and foreign body sensation was significantly higher in female than in male subjects. A significantly higher percentage of males participated in other professional activities in addition to teaching, reported working in a calm environment compared with working in a moderately or severely tense and stressful environment, and rated themselves as calm, slightly stressed and anxious or moderately stressed and anxious rather than very stressed and anxious. A significantly higher percentage of females spent most of their time teaching compared with performing other professional activities, and rated themselves as chatty or impulsive. Conclusion Among university teachers, a significantly higher percentage of females than males reported hoarseness, vocal tract discomfort, neck pain and foreign body sensation. Some risk factors related to work organization, workplace environment, voice care and quality of life variables were related to this higher prevalence in females.

Determinant of Voice Handicap Index Degree as Dysphonia Patients’ Quality of Life Indicator

“…In addition there are structural gender differences in the anatomy of the larynx. Women have shorter vocal folds than men (so that the fundamental frequency of speaking is higher), (Hunter et al 2011), (Korn et al 2018).…”

Prevalencia de los trastornos de la voz en los docentes universidad del magdalena, Colombia 2017-2018

“…La gran limitante del estudio fue que solo se evaluaron bajo visión endoscópica 28 profesores de 53 que presentaron incapacidad moderada y severa, porque estos fueron los únicos que decidieron continuar con el estudio endoscópico de la laringe [13][14][15][16] . En este punto vale la pena precisar que existen dispositivos para diagnósticos endoscópicos más precisos, como la laringoestroboscopia, de los cuales carece la ciudad origen del estudio y que serían motivo de otra investigación.…”

Voice Handicap Index in Iranian Rehabilitation Professors with and Without Vocal Complaints

“…The frequent occurrence of vocal symptoms or complaints in professors impairs performance and contributes to the idea of the future profession changing due to vocal problems (11,12). Studies show that the voice problems of university professors should be studied in a separate group (4,13). A 2017 study by Ahmed et al reported an abnormal voice in 38.8% of participants in a population of university professors (14).…”