Cortical thickness (CT) analyses have provided valuable insights into changes in cortical brain structure after stroke and their association with recovery. Across studies though, relationships between cortical structure and function show inconsistent results. Recent developments in diffusion-weighted imaging of the cortex have paved the way to uncover hidden aspects of stroke-related alterations in cortical microstructure, going beyond CT as a surrogate for cortical macrostructure. We re-analysed clinical and imaging data of 42 well-recovered chronic stroke patients from two independent cohorts (mean age 64 years, 4 left-handed, 71% male, 16 right-sided strokes) and 33 healthy controls of similar age and gender. Cortical fractional anisotropy (FA) and CT values were obtained for six key sensorimotor areas of the contralesional hemisphere. The regions included the primary motor cortex, dorsal and ventral premotor cortex, supplementary and pre-supplementary motor areas, and primary somatosensory cortex. Linear models were estimated for group comparisons between patients and controls, and for correlations between cortical FA and CT and clinical scores. Compared to controls, stroke patients exhibited a reduction in FA in the contralesional ventral premotor cortex (P = 0.005). FA of the other regions, and CT did not show a comparable group difference. Higher FA of the ventral premotor cortex, but not CT, was positively associated with residual grip force in the stroke patients. These data provide novel evidence that the contralesional ventral premotor cortex might constitute a key sensorimotor area particularly susceptible to stroke-related alterations in cortical microstructure as measured by diffusion MRI and they suggest a link between these changes and residual motor output after stroke.