Electro-fuels are seen as a promising alternative to
curb carbon
emissions in the transport sector due to their appealing properties,
similar to those of their fossil counterparts, allowing them to use
current infrastructure and state-of-the-art automotive technologies.
However, their broad implications beyond climate change remain unclear
as previous studies mainly focused on analyzing their carbon footprint.
To fill this gap, here, we evaluated the environmental and economic
impact of Fischer–Tropsch electro-diesel (FT e-diesel) synthesized
from electrolytic H
2
and captured CO
2
. We consider
various power (wind, solar, nuclear, or the current mix) and carbon
sources (capture from the air (DAC) or a coal power plant) while covering
a range of impacts on human health, ecosystems, and resources. Applying
process simulation and life cycle assessment (LCA), we found that
producing e-diesel from wind and nuclear H
2
combined with
DAC CO
2
could reduce the carbon footprint relative to fossil
diesel, leading to burden-shifting in human health and ecosystems.
Also, it would incur prohibitive costs, even when considering externalities
(i.e., indirect costs of environmental impacts). Overall, this work
highlights the need to embrace environmental impacts beyond climate
change in the analysis of alternative fuels and raises concerns about
the environmental appeal of electro-fuels.