The Effect of School Psychologists and Social Workers on School Achievement and Failure: A National Multilevel Study in Chile

Abstract

School achievement and failure have become growing political and social concerns due to the negative consequences of school failure for individuals and society. The inclusive educational movement, which calls for equal access, permanence, participation, and promotion of all students worldwide, poses many challenges for schools and school systems. As a public policy strategy, some countries have provided additional funds for incorporating non-teaching professionals such as school psychologists and social workers in regular K-12 schools. However, there is lack of research on the effects of these psychosocial professionals on student outcomes. This national multilevel study explored the effect of psychologists (n = 8,469) and social workers (n = 3,524) on indicators of eighth-grade (n = 147,531) and 10th-grade (n = 106,347) students' academic achievement and dropout in Chile. A multilevel secondary analysis was performed using national records of non-teaching professionals working as school staff members, achievement scores on the national SIMCE test, and dropout rates based on official records. Results showed that after controlling for individual and school variables known to affect achievement and dropout, schools with psychologists and social workers working as staff members had lower short- and long-term dropout rates. The presence and higher number of school psychologists per school was positively associated with higher math achievement, with a reduced effect in low-SES schools. Lower-SES schools with more social workers had higher math scores. These results support policies that increase funding for school psychologists and social workers, since their incorporation partly explains better school achievement and less school failure when controlling for individual and school characteristics, but emphasize the need to further explore the mechanisms through which school achievement and failure are developed with the support of psychologists and social workers in schools. We discuss the need to regulate the type of prevention and intervention strategies from a whole-school, evidence-based approach, as well as to incorporate psychosocial training modules and comprehensive guidelines as part of professional training programs and as certified requisites for working in schools.

What do Support Professionals do in Schools? Construction and Validation of an Instrument for Assessing Whole-School Prevention and Promotion Strategies

“…In this study, we argue that as part of small- or large-scale universal whole-school prevention efforts, it is possible and necessary to assess the practices that nonteaching support professionals deploy in schools to estimate if and how these practices align with multitiered intervention principles. This is especially necessary in developing countries that have recently incorporated support staff members such as school psychologists and social workers at a mass scale in public schools who due to lack of sufficient training, mandatory requirements for working in schools as support professionals, and lack of policy orientations might be undertrained and tend to reproduce traditional highly individualized forms of interventions (Lebeer et al, 2012).…”

The professional role and exercise of the role of educational assistance professionals in schools with School Integration Programs in Chile

“…The PIE psychologist will mainly perform evaluations of cognitive skills related with the learning process. Their functions are different from those of the psychologist in the School Coexistence program, whose main function is psychosocial, given that they work collaboratively with a social worker in a 'psychosocial duo' (López et al, 2021). Physical therapists should perform functional psychomotor assessment of students with SEN, and support teaching diversification strategies among teachers and the educational community.…”

Factores determinantes el fracaso escolar en España: un análisis socioeducativo de la producción de conocimiento

“…A raíz de esta concepción, el estudio de los factores que determinan el fracaso escolar y las desigualdades sociales en el ámbito de la educación es, en los últimos años, un tema por el que se han inclinado los investigadores sociales, enfocados especialmente a la inclusión, equidad y evaluación de la calidad educativa 33 .…”